Peer Reviews of Disability Access Assessments

Equal Access provides independent peer review services at key stages of a building project. Reviews may cover:
- Peer Reviews of Plan Assessments
- Peer Reviews of Performance Solutions
- Peer Reviews of As-Built Inspections
We can review architectural documentation, access assessment reports, Performance Solutions, expert opinions, professional opinions and completed building works prepared or inspected by other consultants.
Each review considers the relevant project requirements, including the National Construction Code, applicable Australian Standards, the Disability (Access to Premises — Buildings) Standards 2010 and the Disability Discrimination Act 1992, where relevant.
A peer review provides an additional level of independent scrutiny. It can identify omissions, inconsistencies or compliance concerns before the project progresses further.
Peer Reviews of Plan Assessments
A plan assessment can look complete but still overlook important access requirements. Sometimes the issue is a missing dimension. In other cases, the drawings, specifications and access report do not align.
Equal Access can independently review architectural plans, specifications, schedules and supporting access documentation prepared for new buildings, additions, alterations or changes of use.
The review may consider:
- the applicable National Construction Code requirements
- relevant Australian Standards referenced by the NCC
- the Disability (Access to Premises — Buildings) Standards 2010
- access provisions identified within planning approvals, project briefs or contractual requirements
- consistency between the architectural documentation and the access consultant’s report
- whether identified departures have been adequately addressed
- whether further information, clarification or a Performance Solution may be required
Any findings are clearly documented so the project team can respond before construction or certification progresses.
Plan assessment peer reviews may be undertaken for building owners, developers, architects, building surveyors, project managers, financiers, government agencies and other parties seeking an independent review of the documentation.
Peer Reviews of Performance Solutions
Equal Access can peer review access-related Performance Solutions prepared by another consultant.
The review considers whether the relevant NCC Performance Requirements have been correctly identified and whether the assessment method, acceptance criteria, supporting evidence and conclusions are appropriate for the proposed design.
Under Clause A2G2 of the NCC, a Performance Solution must follow a structured process that includes establishing the assessment approach, undertaking the analysis, evaluating the results and documenting the outcome. A performance-based design brief should also establish the scope, relevant performance requirements, acceptance criteria, assessment methods and stakeholder responsibilities.
There may be circumstances in which a client, authority, council, building surveyor, building certifier, or another project stakeholder has concerns about the content or conclusions of a Performance Solution. The concern may relate to the evidence provided, the assessment methodology or whether the report adequately demonstrates compliance.
Our peer review provides an independent technical opinion on the documentation presented. Where concerns are identified, they are set out clearly and supported by reference to the relevant requirements.
Although compliance with the NCC and the Premises Standards addresses important statutory obligations, access to premises may also be relevant under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992. Section 23 of the Act addresses discrimination in relation to access to premises, while the Disability (Access to Premises — Buildings) Standards 2010 establish access requirements applying to specified buildings, building certifiers, developers and building managers.
Peer Reviews of As-Built Inspections
Documentation tells only part of the story. Once construction is complete, the building must reflect what was approved.
Equal Access can undertake an independent inspection of completed or substantially completed building works to compare the as-built conditions against the approved architectural documentation, access assessment reports, Performance Solutions and applicable access requirements.
The inspection may cover:
- accessible paths of travel
- entrances and doorways
- ramps, stairways and handrails
- passenger lifts and platform lifts
- accessible and ambulant sanitary facilities
- signage and tactile information
- hearing augmentation systems
- accessible car parking
- floor surfaces and transitions
- circulation spaces and clearances
- other access features relevant to the building
The resulting peer review report records the items inspected and identifies departures, incomplete work or conditions that do not appear to reflect the approved documentation.
Where particular elements cannot be verified during the inspection, this will be stated. For example, concealed construction, wall reinforcement, in-wall services or other elements hidden by completed finishes may require certificates, construction photographs, shop drawings or other supporting evidence.
As-built peer reviews can be arranged before practical completion, occupancy approval, property acquisition or the release of final project payments. They may also be commissioned where concerns have been raised about work previously assessed or certified by another party.
Who Will Complete Your Peer Review?
Your peer review will be undertaken by experienced disability access consultants with relevant industry qualifications and technical knowledge.
Our team includes:
- accredited members of the Association of Consultants in Access Australia
- consultants with qualifications and experience in architectural design, disability access and risk management
- practitioners experienced in reviewing building documentation, Performance Solutions and completed building works
The reviewer will be selected according to the nature, scale and technical requirements of the project.
